By: Andrew Dabb & Daniel Loflin
**Spoilers**
If you have not yet watched this episode PLEASE go and do so before proceeding!
That joke was from Season 2. THAT JOKE STARTED ALL THE WAY BACK IN SEASON 2! I'm not sure whether this is utterly clever and amazing or utterly stupid and beating a dead...unicorn. Right now I'm going with the former because it made me laugh. And hey - at least we got to finally see a unicorn in
Supernatural. A moonlighting, rainbow-farting, killer unicorn, yeah, but still a unicorn.
Just...wow. Sometimes
Supernatural may be mind-boggling and frustrating feels-wise, but if you stick with it long enough everything will eventually be explained and/or resolved. Even jokes from five seasons ago.
This episode proved that, two seasons out from its original intended ending, this show is still able to balance the laughs and the gross-outs and the feels with delicacy and ease. We also get a return to the concept of Sam's coulrophobia (the man has fought the Devil and yet still cries when he sees a clown...not that I blame him) and an explanation as to
why he's so afraid of clowns. Turns out it was because whenever he was younger Dean would strand him at a Plucky's and go trolling for chicks. Guess this particular phobia really
does stem from a bad childhood memory. And here I was betting that it was because Dean had showed him
IT at too young of an age and Tim Curry had scarred poor Sammy for life. Huh...
Favorite Moments & Random Thoughts:
|
Sam has my sympathy... |
- Right from the opening recap (complete with a montage of Sam and Sam's clown phobia) we know we're in for a good time. Then whenever the episode itself begins with a teaser from later in the episode that involves Sam being chased/mugged by two creepy clowns...well...it just gets better from there on out!
- The episode proper opens with Dean swearing off all beer, booze, and barmaids entirely. The reason for this uncharacteristic act? May I remind all of us what happened just last week with
The Slice Girls? Yeah. At least they're keeping the continuity going even in their 'breather comedy' episodes.
-
"If it bleeds, you can kill it." Heeheehee...hahaha...teeheehee...yeah right!
- This episode has its own, personalized title card.
- The first death is a man who was suckered to death by an octo-vamp. Whenever deaths like this started, I have to admit I had a bit of hope that they were dealing with a trickster. It's a good thing that I'm not a hunter, though, because my prediction was WAY off!
- "Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie? Pizza chain for kids. Actually, more for lazy parents." Ouch.
- So for the first death we have an Octovamp and the second one is a killer unicorn that literally has rainbows coming out of its behind. Starting to see why I suspected it was a trickster?
- The episode keeps cutting back to the original story of Sam being beaten up by two clowns (though he held his own rather well, considering that they didn't bleed and couldn't be killed) with a
24 - style ticking clock to remind us of poor Sam's impending date with Tim Curry's uglier soulbrothers. Seriously...what was up with those clown's teeth?!
- I also laughed probably more than I should have whenever poor Sam was being mugged by those clowns. Classic SPN black comedy!
- Poor Sam! (That was pretty much the sentiment throughout this entire episode!)
DEAN:
"It's not like I left you in jail. I mean, those places are supposed to be fun."
SAM:
"Fun? Uh, they're lame. And they smell like puke. And the ice cream is all grainy."
DEAN:
"All right, don't have one of your episodes, okay?"
- Sam's FACE whenever Dean tells him that he has to go to Plucky's! He looks like he's being led to the block...
- Bear in mind, on a darker note, that all of this is happening to Sam while he's still dealing with Halucifer. I hate to think what he was seeing this entire time.
- On a side note, I don't blame Sam for being emotionally scarred by Plucky's. Even if it
hadn't been because of abandonment issues Dean inadvertently gave him, I still would understand it he came out on the other side a different man. That place is just creepy. Too many fake clowns with empty, creepy eyes are wandering around. The colors are too bright. The music is annoyingly cheerful. And there's too many of those darn mascots that you can't see their eyes...and if
Doctor Who has taught me one thing, it's been that if you can't see something's eyes you shouldn't trust it.
-
"It's just an exercise some pop psychologist came up with. Plus, the owner's obsessed with "aiding children's development." So, the place-mat is a safe way to get kids to talk about their fears. You know, we get them to sketch it in a little box, and – voila! – Plucky magically transforms it into rainbows and candy. Personally, I think it's a load of hooey, but they say that if these fears run wild, then it affects kids long into their adulthood." Well clearly it's still affecting Sam!
- The janitor died in a ball pit in a scene that was eerily reminiscent of
Jaws (had similar music and everything) and the police somehow figure that the BALL WASHER did it?!
- I love the bit with Dean bonding with that kid in Plucky's while Sam played 'bad cop'. Dean may have sworn off of babies and all baby-making activities for the foreseeable future, but that doesn't mean he's not still an excellent big brother/father figure.
- And for some reason his awkwardness about being a grown man hanging around in Plucky's was funny too.
- I laughed whenever he and the kid both agree that the pizza
"Tastes like butt."
- There was a reference to
Breaking Bad in the scene where Dean chases the lion mascot and it turns out that all he's guilty of is shrooming in a ball pit. Come on! Ball pits are bizarre and weird anyway...can you imagine being stoned in one? Urgh!
- So it turns out that Howard was the culprit, in typical
Scooby Doo fashion, using voodoo (of course) to get back at parents he feels are being less than excellent in a twisted revenge plot against his own family. It doesn't really make sense, but it's dark and tragic enough for this show and, let's face it, villainous motivations are usually so re-invented and dramatized anyway that who knows what the original story was!
- Love the time stamp that appears over the finale jump:
- Also, Sam running from the clowns is very reminiscent of Dean in
Yellow Fever running from that little, itty-bitty dog.
- Except clowns are more scary than that dog was.
- Seriously. Clowns are messed up.
- And Sam takes quite a beating from them too. Everything from being whacked with a crowbar to being thrown into the windshield of a car...these clowns are what Pennywise
should have been if they wanted him to be menacing.
- Speaking of Pennywise...is the name Plucky Pennywhistle's a reference to that clown from
IT?
- The way Dean disposes of Howard (by calling up a shade of Howard's dead brother) is surprisingly dark and even cruel for this particular type of episode. It worked, but it feels rather jarring at times.
|
Poor guy looks like he's about to cry... |
- There's just something very funny about the way the clowns burst into glitter. Sam looks like he borrowed Edward's body wash. I'm shocked that Dean didn't make a comment about
that...but maybe vamps in general just hold bad memories for him.
- And at least they both got a laugh out of it. It's suddenly occurred to me that we haven't heard our two boys laugh, really laugh, since Season 5. Sarcastic and sad and humoring, yeah, but not a real laugh. We all needed this.
- Dean apologizes to Sam for psychologically scarring him and the two brothers laugh some more. Oh yeah. We all REALLY needed this.
- And Sam buying the gigantic slinky Dean has been eyeing the entire episode is just the icing on the cake. Perfect ending to a hilarious episode!
This episode is just a joy to watch. It's funny, it's dark, and it delves some more into Sam and Dean's childhoods. It really showcased just what makes a SPN humor episode work so well: all of the black comedy. It was gross in some places and the story was utterly absurd (even for this show) but because of the humor and the characters, it sailed on through the finish line without ever feeling dragged down or too out there to be enjoyable.
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie is a
4/5.
What did you think? Do you agree with my rating? If not - what would you say differently?